Rethinking Protein: What makes a food a good protein source?

Protein is a topic I have discussed countless times as a dietitian-nutritionist specialising in autoimmune conditions and inflammation, with further training in plant-based nutrition. Yet public interest, along with ongoing research, continues to bring it into the spotlight. Protein is one of the nutrients receiving increasing attention from people interested in their health, fitness and maintaining muscle mass. Much of the discussion tends to focus on how much protein we consume and which foods are considered the best sources. Meat, chicken, eggs and dairy have long been closely associated with meeting our protein needs, while plant-based options are still sometimes underestimated.

However, the nutritional value of a food goes far beyond its protein content. Other nutrients it provides, its place within our overall dietary pattern, and the environmental and economic implications of its production and consumption -they all matter. This broader perspective is precisely what a new scientific study seeks to highlight, proposing a more comprehensive way of evaluating protein-rich foods.

A different approach to evaluating foods
Researcher Chris Macdonald, from the University of Cambridge, presented a scoring system in the scientific journal Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems that brings together several different factors to produce an overall score. The approach was applied to 20 protein-rich foods, with the aim of assessing not only their nutritional value but also the wider implications associated with choosing them. The plant-based category included foods such as tofu, lentils, chickpeas, quinoa and various seeds, while animal-based sources included beef, pork, lamb, eggs, cod, tuna and popular cheeses. The environmental assessment considered greenhouse gas emissions, land use, freshwater consumption and water pollution. The human health and accessibility assessment took into account nutritional characteristics such as saturated fat, sodium and cholesterol, as well as essential amino acid content, cost and food availability.

What makes this approach particularly interesting is the way these factors are considered together. Rather than evaluating a food based on a single characteristic, the aim is to understand the bigger picture and the potential trade-offs involved in choosing it.

In this particular assessment, tofu achieved the highest overall score, while all five foods ranking at the top were plant-based. Conversely, the five lowest-ranking foods were all animal-based.

These findings are interesting because they highlight the potential of plant-based protein sources when food choices are assessed against more than one nutritional or environmental criterion. It is important, however, to clarify that this is a new food assessment framework, not a clinical trial directly comparing the health effects of plant-based and animal-based diets. The ranking reflects the results of this particular model; it does not establish that one food is the best choice for everyone or in every circumstance.

Why plant-based protein sources deserve more space on our plates
Beyond the findings of this particular study, there are compelling nutritional reasons to increase the presence of plant-based foods in our everyday diets. Legumes such as lentils, chickpeas and beans provide protein, dietary fibre, folate and minerals. Soybeans and soy-based products, including tofu and tempeh, are also valuable sources of protein. Nuts and seeds, meanwhile, contribute protein, unsaturated fats and a range of other beneficial nutrients. One of the main advantages of most minimally processed plant foods is that they offer much more than a single nutrient. They form part of a broader dietary pattern that can help us increase our fibre intake and replace some saturated fats with unsaturated fats, depending on the foods we choose.

Legumes, in particular, deserve a more prominent place in our weekly meals. Although they are a cornerstone of the traditional Greek diet, they are not always eaten as frequently as they could be. Bringing them back to the table, not simply as a side dish but as the main ingredient in a meal, is an easy way to enrich our diets with plant-based protein.

At the same time, a broader shift towards more plant-based dietary patterns can offer environmental benefits. Producing many plant-based protein sources is associated with lower greenhouse gas emissions and less land use compared with producing meat from ruminant animals, such as beef. The precise environmental footprint, of course, varies depending on the food, production methods and supply chain involved.

Do we need to combine plant proteins at every meal?
A common concern about plant-based eating relates to protein quality and whether we can obtain all the essential amino acids our bodies need. It is true that some plant protein sources contain lower proportions of certain essential amino acids than others. However, this does not mean we must combine specific foods in the same meal to ensure adequate protein intake.

For most healthy adults, getting enough protein overall and eating a variety of plant foods throughout the day are more important than strictly combining particular foods at every meal. Soy, for example, is a plant-based protein source that provides all nine essential amino acids. Therefore, a diet that includes legumes, soy products, whole grains, nuts and seeds can meet our protein requirements, provided it is appropriately planned in terms of both quantity and variety.

Protein needs, after all, are not the same for everyone. Age, physical activity, overall energy intake and certain health conditions can all influence how much protein we require. This is why nutritional needs should be assessed individually, particularly for people with higher requirements or specific dietary restrictions.

How can we include more plant-based protein in our daily diet?
Increasing our intake of plant-based protein does not require complicated recipes or a complete overhaul of our eating habits. We can start with a few small, realistic changes.

  • Make legumes the centrepiece of a meal. A lentil salad, chickpeas cooked with vegetables or hummus served with wholegrain bread can all make satisfying and nutritious meals.
  • Give tofu and tempeh a try. They can be marinated, baked or cooked with vegetables, and added to salads, warm dishes and sandwiches.
  • Give your breakfast a protein boost. Oats, nuts, seeds and soy milk can all contribute to your daily protein intake as part of a balanced breakfast.
  • Make room for whole grains. Wholegrain bread, bulgur wheat and quinoa also contribute protein while providing additional nutrients.
  • Make gradual substitutions. There is no need to eliminate animal products straight away. We can start by replacing some meat-based meals with dishes built around legumes or soy.

The goal is not to keep adding more and more protein to our diets regardless of our actual needs. Instead, we should focus on choosing high-quality protein sources and putting together meals that provide adequate protein, dietary fibre and a variety of nutrients.

It is also important to remember that not all plant-based products are equally beneficial. A food does not automatically become healthy simply because it is labelled as plant-based. Ultra-processed meat alternatives, plant-based sweets and savoury snacks may be high in salt, saturated fat or added sugars. The quality of our food choices therefore remains crucial.

This new approach to evaluating protein sources gives us a valuable opportunity to look at our dietary choices more holistically. We do not need to search for one single food that can meet all our nutritional needs. What matters is making the most of the variety nature provides and building a balanced dietary pattern that benefits both our health and the environment, while making us more aware of the wider impact of our food choices.

Source:
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems – 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1677796